Every year, employers grapple with the same question after the holiday season: once the official Christmas party is over, do the normal workplace rules still apply?
A recent Fair Work Commission decision suggests the answer may be “yes”, even when employees have left the venue, the event has ended, and the employer is no longer involved.
In Bell v Arts Centre Melbourne [2026] FWC 3212, the Fair Work Commission upheld the summary dismissal of an employee who physically assaulted a colleague at a nearby bar after attending his employer’s Christmas party. The decision provides a timely reminder that work-related obligations do not automatically disappear when employees clock off or move to an unofficial “after party”.

What Happened?
Arts Centre Melbourne hosted its staff Christmas party in December 2024. Following the official event, a number of employees walked to a nearby public bar located approximately 200 metres from the venue. Around 20 employees attended the informal gathering.
During a conversation between two employees who had not previously met, one employee used the phrase “that’s gay“. The colleague took offence and responded forcefully. The discussion escalated and, as the employees walked away, one employee struck the other in the head with sufficient force to send him backwards into an outdoor heater and onto the ground.
The employer conducted an investigation, suspended the employee on pay, put the allegations to him, provided an opportunity to respond and ultimately terminated his employment for serious misconduct. The employee subsequently lodged an unfair dismissal application.

“But It Happened After The Party”
A central issue before the Commission was whether the conduct was sufficiently connected to employment.
The employee argued that the incident occurred after working hours, away from the workplace, and at a venue that was not organised, authorised or controlled by the employer. Traditionally, these factors have been important considerations when determining whether out-of-hours conduct can justify disciplinary action.
The Commission nevertheless found that a sufficient nexus existed between the conduct and the employment relationship.
Several factors were influential:
- the employees were only together because they had attended the work function;
- the bar was located in close proximity to the workplace and function venue;
- the gathering occurred immediately after the official event;
- the employees involved had no relationship outside work;
- the employer’s policies and contractual obligations required employees to maintain standards of safety and respectful behaviour; and
- the incident had ongoing consequences within the workplace.
In other words, while the Christmas party may have technically ended, the employment connection had not.

Physical Violence Will Rarely Be Excused
The employee also attempted to argue that his conduct was a response to the aggressive behaviour and language of his colleague.
The Commission rejected that argument.
Importantly, the decision makes clear that offensive language, raised voices or heated exchanges will not ordinarily justify a physical response. The Commission considered the force used significant and found the employee’s actions were neither necessary nor proportionate in the circumstances. Whether the incident was described as a punch, push or shove made little practical difference given the resulting impact on the other employee.

The Importance of Policies
One aspect of the decision that employers should note is the weight given to the employer’s behavioural expectations.
The employee’s contract required compliance with organisational policies and values, including requirements relating to safety, respect and appropriate conduct. The Commission considered those obligations when assessing whether the conduct was capable of damaging the employment relationship.
This serves as a useful reminder that workplace policies are not simply administrative documents. Well-drafted policies can help establish the standards expected of employees and support disciplinary action where serious misconduct occurs.
However, policies alone will not save an otherwise flawed process.

The Real Takeaway for Employers
The lesson from this case is not that employers can regulate every aspect of an employee’s private life.
Rather, it reinforces a well-established principle: out-of-hours conduct may still justify disciplinary action where there is a sufficient connection to employment.
Whether that connection exists will always depend on the facts.
Employers considering disciplinary action arising from after-hours conduct should still ensure they:
- identify the connection between the conduct and employment;
- conduct a thorough and impartial investigation;
- clearly put allegations to the employee;
- provide a genuine opportunity to respond; and
- ensure any disciplinary outcome is proportionate to the conduct established.
The fact that an incident occurred after the official Christmas party, at another venue, or outside ordinary working hours will not necessarily place it beyond an employer’s reach.
As Bell v Arts Centre Melbourne demonstrates, sometimes the work Christmas party does not end when employees leave the venue. For the purposes of workplace obligations and standards of behaviour, it may continue well into the after-party.
If you are unsure whether your employment contracts or policies adequately protect your business, we can assist with a targeted review and update.
Get in touch!
If you’ve got any burning questions about this information or you’re not sure how it impacts your business, reach out to our team by email hello@flawlesshr.com.au





