High Income Doesn’t Always Mean Award-Free

One of the more common misconceptions we encounter when reviewing employment arrangements is the assumption that a senior employee earning a substantial salary cannot be covered by a modern award.

In practice, it is rarely that simple.

A recent Fair Work Commission (FWC) decision [1] involving a Commercial Leasing Director earning above the high-income threshold serves as a timely reminder that award coverage can extend further than many employers expect and that remuneration alone does not determine whether an employee is covered by an award.

While the employee in this case was ultimately unsuccessful, the decision highlights an issue employers should not overlook: award coverage is determined by the nature of the business and the duties being performed, not simply an employee’s title, seniority or salary.

The employee was employed as Commercial Leasing Director for a Melbourne property group and, following the termination of his employment, sought to commence an unfair dismissal application.

To access unfair dismissal protections, employees who earn more than the high-income threshold generally need to be covered by a modern award or enterprise agreement.

The employee argued that he was covered by the Real Estate Industry Award and should be classified as a Real Estate Employee Level 2.

The employer disagreed, arguing both that it was not covered by the Real Estate Industry Award and that the employee’s role was not captured by any classification within the award.

Interestingly, the Commission rejected one of the employer’s key arguments.

The employer contended that it did not operate in the real estate industry because it developed, owned and leased its own properties rather than acting as an agent for third-party clients.

The Commission disagreed, finding that the business was engaged in the real estate industry as defined by the Award.

The employee’s claim ultimately failed for a different reason. While many of his day-to-day duties aligned with tasks found within the Award classifications, the Commission concluded that the true purpose of the role and the level of responsibility went significantly beyond any classification available under the Award.

As a result, the employee was not award-covered and, because he earned above the high-income threshold, was unable to pursue an unfair dismissal claim.

The mistake many employers make is assuming that an employee ceases to be award-covered once they are promoted, earn a six-figure salary or take on management responsibilities.

That isn’t how award coverage works.

Modern awards do not disappear simply because an employee earns more money.

In many cases, highly paid employees can continue to be covered by a modern award where the duties they perform and the nature of the role continue to align with an award classification.

This issue has become increasingly important as employees and advisers look more closely at award coverage in disputes involving:

  • unfair dismissal eligibility;
  • overtime claims;
  • penalty rates;
  • annualised salary arrangements;
  • minimum wage compliance;
  • underpayment claims; and
  • interpretation of set-off clauses.


An employer may pay an employee well above the minimum award requirements but still have obligations under the award.

We also regularly encounter employers who believe that because they have included a set-off or salary absorption clause in an employment contract, the award effectively ceases to apply.

Again, that is not how modern awards operate.

A properly drafted set-off arrangement may allow an employer to offset certain award entitlements against a higher salary. However, it does not remove award coverage itself.

The award may still apply for a range of purposes, including:

  • classification;
  • consultation obligations;
  • rostering requirements;
  • dispute resolution procedures; and
  • determining whether an employee can access unfair dismissal protections despite earning above the high-income threshold.


The starting point must always be determining whether an employee is award-covered. Only then can an employer assess how a contractual set-off arrangement interacts with those obligations.

Although the employee was unsuccessful in this matter, the decision continues a broader trend of employees testing the boundaries of award coverage.

Over the years, we have seen employees occupying surprisingly senior positions argue they remain award-covered. One example is the SCHADS Award, which has one of the broadest coverage clauses in the modern award system and has previously been considered capable of extending well beyond frontline operational employees to the Chief Executive Officer of a business.

This creates a degree of risk for employers who assume seniority alone removes award obligations.

It is not difficult to imagine a senior manager, executive or highly remunerated specialist successfully arguing award coverage where the role continues to sit within the scope of an applicable classification structure.

This decision is a good reminder to periodically review:

  • whether employees are genuinely award-free;
  • whether classifications remain accurate as positions evolve;
  • whether salary absorption provisions are correctly drafted;
  • whether employees earning above the high-income threshold may still be award-covered; and
  • whether remuneration arrangements leave employees better off than their minimum award entitlements.


Waiting until a dismissal, underpayment claim or workplace dispute arises is often too late.

The employee in this case ultimately fell outside the Real Estate Industry Award and was unable to pursue an unfair dismissal claim. However, that should not distract employers from the broader lesson.

The Commission was prepared to closely examine the possibility that a highly paid director was award-covered and rejected the employer’s argument that the Award did not apply to its industry in the first place.

For employers, the message is simple: a high salary, an impressive title or a contractual set-off clause will not automatically remove award coverage. Before assuming an employee is award-free, it is worth taking a closer look at the duties they perform and the award landscape that may apply to them.

[1] Sam Fogarty v Kokoda Property Group (Melbourne) Pty Ltd [2026] FWC 3147 (20 August 2026)

If you are unsure whether your employment contracts or policies adequately protect your business, we can assist with a targeted review and update.

Get in touch!


More blog articles.

Casual in Name Only? The Fair Work Commission Looks Beyond the Contract

A common misconception among employers is that a casual employee’s classification as a casual depends heavily on the terms of the employment contract. However, a recent Fair Work Commission decision serves as a reminder that, in some circumstances, the reality of the working relationship can be just as important as the label attached to it.

Read More »

When Does a Work Christmas Party Actually End?

Every year, employers grapple with the same question after the holiday season: once the official Christmas party is over, do the normal workplace rules still apply?
A recent Fair Work Commission decision suggests the answer may be “yes”, even when employees have left the venue, the event has ended, and the employer is no longer involved.

Read More »

When Good Intentions Lead to Serious Misconduct

A recent Fair Work Commission (FWC) decision serves as a timely reminder that an employee’s intentions are only one part of the equation. In some circumstances, a serious lapse in judgement can justify dismissal, even where there was no malicious intent.

Read More »

The Casual Conversion Case That Put AI in the Spotlight

Artificial intelligence is changing the way workplaces operate. From drafting policies and position descriptions through to assisting with investigations, performance management and legal research, employers are increasingly turning to AI-powered tools to improve efficiency and reduce administrative burden.

Read More »

Australian Non-Compete Reforms: What Employers Need to Know

The Australian Government has proposed some of the most significant changes to employment restraints in decades. If passed in their current form, the reforms would dramatically limit an employer’s ability to prevent former employees from joining competitors or starting competing businesses.

Read More »